DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information
  1. Wrought FeCrAl alloy (C26M) cladding behavior and burst under simulated loss-of-coolant accident conditions

    Cladding burst experiments for FeCrAl cladding were performed in the Severe Accident Test Station facility at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. These experiments were simulated using the BISON fuel performance code to better understand the cladding plastic behavior and failure under simulated loss-of-coolant accident conditions. 3D cladding surface boundary conditions were generated using composite axial and azimuthal profiles from experiment thermocouple data. To improve the simulation analysis capabilities in BISON for cladding burst behavior, new thermal creep, plasticity, and failure stress models specific to C26M, a wrought FeCrAl alloy, were developed and implemented. Initial cladding burst results indicated a general underpredictionmore » in the failure temperature of the six cladding burst simulations versus the observed failure temperatures. Close investigation of the experiment timing versus the underlying tensile test data revealed that, compared with the tensile specimens, the cladding tubes did not experience the same long holding time at high temperatures. New tensile tests were performed at high temperatures using a temperature ramp similar to the simulated loss-of-coolant accident experiments. These new tensile curves showed an approximately 80% increase in the ultimate tensile strength of the C26M alloy, indicating that a holding time of 10 min at 700 °C and 800 °C allows annealing to change the material microstructure. Using the updated tensile properties, the burst temperatures and stresses from the simulations showed remarkable agreement with the experimental results. This study was then extended by varying the initial pressure to highlight the burst temperature difference between standard Zircaloy-4 and C26M cladding under equivalent conditions. The results show that C26M has a burst temperature that is approximately 70–130 K greater than that of Zircaloy-4. In conclusion, these modeling predictions can be further improved by collecting high-temperature tensile data for C26M beyond the temperature ranges used in this work.« less
  2. Environmental barrier coatings on SiC without a silicon bond coating: oxidation resistance, failure modes, and future improvements

    Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) are used to mitigate chemical reactions between SiC ceramic matrix composite (CMC) components and the H2O in combustion gas in turbine hot sections. CMCs are currently temperature-limited by the Si-bond coating, which melts at ~ 1414 °C. This work explores EBCs where the bond coating was removed to achieve higher operating temperatures. Various versions of enhanced roughness SiC were utilized to improve EBC adhesion to the substrates prior to 1 h furnace cycle testing in steam at 1250–1425 °C. The enhanced SiC roughness resulted in short coating lifetimes as the roughness was oxidized away with SiO2more » formation. Further, isothermal furnace exposures at 1400–1600 °C showed Yb2Si2O7/Yb2SiO5 EBC microstructural changes, resulting in premature debonding from the substrates. Finally, this work provides baseline requirements for the development of both next-generation EBCs and bond coating strategies to overcome the current limitation of the Si-bond coating melting temperature.« less
  3. Finite Element Modeling of the Phase Change in Thermally-Grown SiO2 in SiC Systems for Gas Turbines

    The operating lifetimes of SiC-based components in combustion environments are directly linked to the adhesion of the protective environmental barrier coating (EBC) layer. One of the major known failure modes for EBCs is the formation of a thick SiO2 thermally grown oxide (TGO), which decreases coating adhesion and encourages eventual coating spallation. The effect of the TGO thickness under Yb2Si2O7 EBCs on silicon carbide was investigated using finite element models (FEMs) with various interfacial architectures and SiO2 TGO thicknesses. Further, the FEMs incorporated a user-defined material to simulate the volume contraction of the TGO during the silica phase transformation frommore » β-cristobalite to α-cristobalite upon cooling from the stress-free state at 1350°C to room temperature. Systems with and without a silicon bond coating intermediary layer were assessed. It was shown that the TGO phase transformation stress (1.6–1.7 GPa) dominated the increase in stress in the TGO and EBC layers. Furthermore, it was found that stress increase in the TGO was independent of TGO thickness and interface geometry. These results indicate that stabilization of the TGO to mitigate the phase transformation could dramatically improve the performance of SiC-base components with EBCs.« less
  4. In-situ determination of strain during transient burst testing and the temperature dependence of Zircaloy-4 claddings

    Understanding fuel system behavior during postulated loss-of-coolant accidents is pertinent for continued safe and efficient operation of light water reactors, particularly as higher burnups are being pursued and safety margins re-evaluated. Conventional mechanical models for the incumbent Zr alloys typically rely on the assumption that steady-state creep is the dominant fuel cladding response during transient accident conditions. To investigate this assumption, simulated accident burst testing was performed on Zircaloy-4 claddings with balloon behavior measured in-situ. Here, two distinct loading conditions were utilized during burst testing: (1) constant-gas-inventory where pressure was allowed to increase with temperature and (2) constant pressure. In-situmore » strains and strain rates were measured via 2-dimensional digital image correlation techniques and synchronized with temperature to determine deformation dependencies. The temperature dependence of strain rate was characterized by a two segment Arrhenius relationship, with a distinct transition between the high and low temperature/strain regimes. The average activation energy of the lower temperature/strain regime was 328 ± 25 kJ/mol, in agreement with the ~320 kJ/mol used for conventional LOCA models. However, the higher temperature/strain segment, which encompassed most of ballooning, showed increased activation energies as well as a dependence on whether the burst region was in view. For tests that burst away from the camera view, the average high temperature/strain segment activation energy was 635 ± 150 kJ/mol. For samples where the rupture opening formed in view, the average activation energy was 1015 ± 179 kJ/mol. This observed shift in temperature dependence indicates a transition in deformation mechanism at the end of life, possibly to time independent failure mechanisms, which has not yet been visualized in the literature for Zr alloys. Parameters at the transition points were analyzed to determine thresholds for this change in behavior, which occurred at an average hoop strain of 6.9 ± 2.1 %.« less
  5. Environmental barrier coatings on enhanced roughness SiC: Effect of plasma spraying conditions on properties and performance

    Environmental barrier coatings for SiC/SiC composites are limited by the melting temperature of the Si bond coating near 1414°C. Systems without a bond coating may be required for future turbine applications where material temperatures go beyond 1350 °C. Here, enhanced roughness SiC substrates were developed to assess coating adhesion without the bond coating. Two EBCs with different YbMS/YbDS ratios were produced via modified plasma spraying parameters. Coating microstructure, thermal expansion, and modulus were measured for comparison of coating properties. Cyclic steam exposures at 1350°C were performed to assess oxidation resistance. The EBC with increased concentration of Yb2SiO5 secondary phase displayedmore » a higher CTE, which is typically expected to decrease adhesion lifetimes due to an increase in stress upon thermal cycling. Yet, the EBC chemistry with increased Yb2SiO5 concentration was able to experience longer cycling times prior to coating delamination, likely due to interface interactions with the substrate and the thermally grown oxide.« less
  6. Raman spectroscopic characterization of SiO2 phase transformation and Si substrate stress relevant to EBC performance

    To accurately model the long-term durability of environmental barrier coatings (EBCs), a more complete understanding of the phase composition and transformations of the thermally grown oxide SiO2 (TGO) is desired. For the TGO formed during thermal cycling in steam, cristobalite formation and the subsequent β- to α-cristobalite transformation has been identified as a potentially life-limiting mechanism. In this study, Raman micro-spectroscopy was used to quantify the cristobalite transformation on a polycrystalline Si coupon that was exposed to steam at 1350°C for 100 h. The phase transformation was mapped at 200–260°C on the TGO surface at different ramp rates using amore » heating stage and a micro-positioning stage. The stress in the Si substrate was also determined using Raman spectroscopy by measuring the stress induced peak shift. The α→β phase transformation produced a 300–500 MPa tensile stress in the Si substrate, which compared well to the stress predicted from the volumetric expansion of the cristobalite. In conclusion, quantifying the phase transformation and residual stress are critical tools in developing the next generation of high performance EBCs.« less
  7. Long term oxidation of NiCoCrAlY coated Ni-based superalloys: A comparison of observed and simulated interdiffusion

    Lifetimes of MCrAlY-type coatings can easily surpass 25 kh when the criteria of ß-depletion is used. To reduce experimental effort, it’s necessary to develop models capable of simulating interdiffusion and oxidation. In the present study, NiCoCrAlY coatings were high velocity oxyfuel deposited on PWA 1483, MARM247, and CMSX-4 substrates, and samples were exposed at 900 °C for 5–20 kh in air+10 vol%H2O to study interdiffusion rates. Here, Thermo-Calc/DICTRA was used to reproduce the observed differences, and microstructures were compared. Based on the agreement between calculated and observed rates, simulations were projected past the experimental exposures, utilizing ß-depletion as lifetime criteria.
  8. BISON validation to in situ cladding burst test and high-burnup LOCA experiments

    The process for developing and qualifying nuclear fuels for commercial nuclear application requires fundamental material development, characterization, and design; out-of-pile testing on unirradiated materials; integral fuel rod irradiations, testing, and postirradiation examinations; and transient analyses. The historical approach depends on the generation of large empirical datasets and series of integral fuel rod irradiations, and this approach ultimately takes ~20 years—or sometimes longer—to acquire data through extensive sequential testing. Thus, the qualification and eventual deployment of new fuel systems constitute a long process. However, recent technological advancements have provided researchers the opportunity to perform out-of-cell, in situ measurements to assess materialmore » performance for the duration of the experiment. One such example of this capability is the use of digital image coordination and thermal imaging to assess Zircaloy cladding performance under a simulated loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) transient condition. In situ measurements generally provide high-fidelity strain, strain rates, and temperature surface maps. This is critical for the US nuclear industry, which is actively developing a technical basis to support extending the peak rod average burnup from 62 to ~75 GWd/tU and the deployment of accident-tolerant fuel. However, the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) outlined in its research information letter several technical issues that the industry must address before extending burnup. One topic of specific interest is understanding the cladding balloon and rupture geometry during the LOCA heat-up phase. By leveraging these advanced in situ capabilities, this work used in situ data generated from a simulated LOCA to better understand high-temperature creep and its effect on Zircaloy balloon and rupture performance. Here, this work used the BISON fuel performance code to assess the high-temperature creep model predictions with in situ data.« less
  9. Effects of Cr/Zircaloy-4 coating qualities for enhanced accident tolerant fuel cladding

    Cr-coated zirconium alloys represent a modern approach to enhance cladding safety during accident scenarios. Two high-power impulse magnetron sputtered Cr-coated Zry-4 systems were subjected to simulated loss-of-coolant accident conditions to investigate cladding performance. The first Cr-coating (4.8 µm thick) was deposited onto Zry-4 cladding and exhibited through-thickness cracking while the second Cr-coating (6.8 µm thick) was deposited with improved deposition parameters onto polished Zry-4 and exhibited no cracking. During burst testing, the coating with a higher density of defects failed to consistently reduce oxidation and exhibited similar burst behavior as Zry-4. In contrast, the second Cr-coating reduced ZrO2 formation throughmore » formation of Cr2O3 and displayed enhanced burst temperatures by ~80 °C compared to Zry-4. Utilizing an empirical relation for burst behavior of zirconium alloys, the 6.8 µm Cr/Zry-4 system displayed enhanced burst temperatures equivalent to an effective 0.464 mm increase in Zry-4 wall thickness, highlighting the value of continuous Cr coatings for accident scenarios.« less
...

Search for:
All Records
Creator / Author
"Kane, Kenneth"

Refine by:
Article Type
Availability
Journal
Creator / Author
Publication Date
Research Organization